Prosecutors Allege Huawei Promoted Leaders Who Lied, Broke the Law

The logo of Huawei is seen at the Viva Technology conference dedicated to innovation and startups at Porte de Versailles exhibition center in Paris, France, on June 12, 2025. Benoit Tessier/File Photo/Reuters

NEW YORK CITY—Huawei Technologies’ top management took the lead in setting a culture of lying, stealing, and cheating all for the purpose of developing Huawei into a global telecom leader, Assistant U.S. Attorney Meredith Arfa alleged on Nov. 16.

“The leaders not only modeled the behavior, they approved documents to lie, cheat, and steal,” said Arfa in closing remarks that lasted well over four hours.

A packed courtroom and overflow room observed as the multiyear investigation and trial against China’s largest telecom device manufacturer came to a close.

Arfa alleged that top company officers who made false statements to Congress and financial institutions were promoted.

Evidence presented at trial included an internal memo listing awards of 2,000, 1,000, 500, and 200 renminbi for collecting information from Huawei’s competitors. The amount of the award allegedly depended on the value and confidentiality of the information stolen, such as a business road map for 2,000 yuan, or business documents for 1,000 yuan. The memo allegedly included a dedicated email address where encrypted intellectual property could be submitted for review.

“Lies came from the highest levels of the company,” said Arfa. The government alleged that founder Ren Zhengfei “dismissed and mocked concerns about employee theft,” and noted that Ren, when interviewed by the FBI in 2007, assured the FBI that Huawei respected intellectual property rights.

“Huawei lied to business partners, to journalists, to banks, and the U.S. Congress,” Arfa said.

The government presented evidence of Huawei entering into non-disclosure agreements with T-Mobile and antennae technology company Quintel with the alleged aim of acquiring the companies’ proprietary technology. Internal emails from Huawei employees allegedly present the company as eager to acquire the intellectual property to avoid the costs of research and development.

Arfa alleged that Huawei staff working to acquire semiconductor company CNEX Labs’ technology put in an email that Huawei needed CNEX’s solid state drive technology to gain a competitive edge for its own products. Arfa said the employee dared to write it out “because stealing tech was so ingrained in Huawei culture he never thought of concealing.”

“While Huawei was pretending to be a partner, Huawei was plotting to steal that technology,” said Arfa. “It’s time to finally hold Huawei to account.”

Arfa also noted senior leadership including Cathy Meng, also known as Meng Wanzhou, and senior leaders based in the United States and China who continued in their roles or were promoted after allegedly covering up for the company.

Meng lied to HSBC Bank about Huawei’s relationship with subsidiary Skycom, which operated in Iran in violation of U.S. sanctions, according to the Department of Justice. Meng admitted to making the false statements about Skycom in a deferred prosecution agreement with the DOJ in 2021. Meng continued in her role as chief financial officer and was promoted to serve in the role of rotating chairman.

Prosecutors also cited Charles Ding, who testified to Congress in 2012 that Huawei was not violating U.S. sanctions on Iran and that it did not provide the Iranian government with surveillance technology. Meng and Ding presented Skycom as an independent company, while prosecutors presented evidence that Skycom operated as a subsidiary of Huawei.

“He did not walk into Congress and go rogue,” Arfa alleged of Ding, “Ding told the same lies Meng told to banks.”

Huawei has argued that incidents involving employees stealing intellectual property from T-Mobile and Fujitsu were not a coordinated effort but rather employees going rogue.

When incidents of intellectual property theft were discovered, “Huawei acted appropriately in all three incidents,” including by firing the employee caught taking pictures of a Fujitsu device at a conference, said Huawei defense attorney Brian Heberlig.

Heberlig argued that to prove a racketeering conspiracy, the government must prove that the “same people agreed to carry out the same criminal plan.” The incidents cited by the government are isolated and insufficient to prove that there was some “blueprint for a criminal conspiracy,” he said.

Huawei’s defense team will present its closing arguments on Nov. 17.

We had a problem loading this article. Please enable javascript or use a different browser. If the issue persists, please visit our help center.

 

Read More

Leave a Reply