The fate of Vice-President Sara Duterte-Carpio’s impeachment once again rests with the Philippine Supreme Court after the Senate voted to “archive” – but not dismiss – the charges against her, effectively putting the prospect of a trial on hold.
Advertisement
In a late Wednesday vote of 19-4-1, senators chose to set aside the Articles of Impeachment transmitted by the House of Representatives in February, following a controversial court ruling that deemed the impeachment proceedings unconstitutional.
While no trial ever began, the Senate had been expected to act as the impeachment court under the constitution.
Legal experts say the trial could still theoretically proceed if the Supreme Court reverses its decision on a pending motion for reconsideration. University of the Philippines law professor Barry Gutierrez said the Senate could then retrieve the articles from the archives and proceed with the trial, though he doubted the high court would risk a “fiercer storm of criticism” by dismissing the motions as moot.
On the other side of the debate, Senate Deputy Minority Leader Vicente Sotto III had a blunter view, telling This Week in Asia that the trial was now “buried” and an archived motion was “a dead motion”.
Advertisement
Duterte-Carpio was impeached by the Philippine House of Representatives in February on charges including large-scale corruption involving confidential funds and an alleged assassination plot targeting President Ferdinand Marcos Jnr, his wife, and the House Speaker.